By the Smith Commerce High School Liaison team, current Smith Commerce students. Updated .
TL;DR
- Smith Commerce, Rotman Commerce, Schulich BBA and Laurier BBA start business courses in year one, while Ivey HBA starts in year three.
- High school students apply to Ivey for AEO status and spend their first two years in another Western program.
- Smith, Ivey AEO and Schulich all require a supplementary application alongside your grades.
- Smith doesn't offer co-op, and Laurier's optional business co-op includes three four-month work terms.
If you're applying to business in Ontario, your shortlist probably includes some mix of Queen's, Ivey, Rotman, Schulich and Laurier. We're Smith Commerce students, so we're obviously fans of Queen's, but we also have friends at every one of these schools, and they're all strong programs. This guide sticks to how each program is set up, using each school's own website, so you can compare them on the things that matter to you.
We won't tell you which school is "best." That depends on how you learn, where you want to live, and what kind of experience you want. If the degree names are part of the confusion, our explainer on what a Bachelor of Commerce is covers BCom and BBA degrees.
How do Queen's Commerce, Ivey, Rotman, Schulich and Laurier compare?
The biggest differences between these programs are in how you get in and when you start business courses.
| Smith Commerce (Queen's) | Ivey HBA (Western) | Rotman Commerce (U of T) | Schulich BBA (York) | Lazaridis BBA (Laurier) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| City | Kingston | London | Toronto | Toronto | Waterloo |
| Entry from high school | Direct entry into Commerce | Advanced Entry Opportunity (AEO) status; HBA starts in year 3 | Admission to first year, most with Guaranteed Admission | Direct entry | Direct entry |
| Business courses start | Year 1 | Year 3 (years 1 and 2 in any Western program) | Year 1 | Year 1 | Year 1 |
| Supplementary application | Yes, mandatory (written + two video responses) | Yes, for AEO | Check Rotman's site | Yes, weighted equally with grades | Check Laurier's site |
| Co-op | No co-op; internships through the career centre | Check Ivey's site | Check Rotman's site | Check Schulich's site | Optional co-op, apply in year 1 |
Sources: Smith Commerce, Ivey AEO, Rotman Commerce academic calendar, Schulich BBA, Laurier BBA. Where we've written "check the site," the school's page we read didn't state it clearly, and we'd rather send you there than guess.
Is Queen's Commerce better than Ivey?
Neither is better for everyone. They're built differently: Smith admits you straight into Commerce from high school, while Ivey's HBA starts in year three. That's the main thing to understand.
At Smith, you're admitted straight into Commerce from high school. You start business courses in your first year with the same class you'll graduate with, and you choose electives and areas of focus in third and fourth year.
At Ivey, high school students apply for AEO status, which is conditional pre-admission to the Honours Business Administration (HBA) program. You spend your first two years at Western or one of its affiliated colleges (Huron or King's) in any program you choose, then join Ivey in year 3. To keep AEO status, Ivey requires a two-year average of at least 80% (78% in Engineering), plus other progression requirements. Ivey says about two-thirds of the HBA class have AEO status, and the rest join from Western and other universities.
Ivey also notes its first round of AEO offers comes at the end of March, with most offers in April and May.
So the question is really about what you want. If you know you want business from day one, direct entry might suit you. If you want two years in another field (say, engineering or science) before business, Ivey's model is designed for that.
What's the difference between Queen's and Western?
Beyond the Smith and Ivey structures above, the biggest difference is location. Queen's is in Kingston, on Lake Ontario between Toronto and Montreal. Western is in London, Ontario.
Visiting both is the best way to compare, and HSL runs Goodes Hall tours with the Smith Commerce Office on select weekdays at 10am and 3pm (see our tours page). Our Goodes Hall guide covers what you'll see on a visit to Smith.
How does Queen's Commerce compare to Rotman Commerce?
The main differences are location and how you specialize. Rotman is in downtown Toronto and most students choose a specialist program after first year, while Smith has a shared core and no formal majors.
Rotman Commerce is at the University of Toronto's St. George campus in downtown Toronto. According to U of T's academic calendar, most students are admitted to first year with a Rotman Commerce Guaranteed Admission, and they choose their specialist program after first year if they meet the Guaranteed Admission requirements.
At Smith, there are no formal majors. Everyone takes the same core in years one and two, then you can focus in areas like accounting, finance, marketing, analytics or international business in years three and four, or stay a generalist.
If being in downtown Toronto matters to you, Rotman and Schulich are both in the city. If you want a campus town where most of your life happens within walking distance, Kingston is a big part of the Queen's experience.
How does Queen's Commerce compare to Schulich?
Schulich's BBA at York University is direct entry, like Smith. Schulich weights two things equally: your academic performance and your supplementary application. Its supplementary application deadline for fall 2027 is February 1, 2027, with an optional early consideration deadline of November 23, 2026. Schulich offers an exchange term at one of 66 partner schools.
Smith also uses grades plus a mandatory Supp App (due February 15, 2027), which Smith says weighs heavily in decisions. Our guide to Queen's Commerce requirements covers the courses and average Smith asks for. Smith's exchange program has 120+ partner schools in 45+ regions, with no additional tuition.
How does Queen's Commerce compare to Laurier BBA?
Laurier's BBA at the Lazaridis School in Waterloo is direct entry, and its standout feature is co-op. Laurier says you apply for co-op in first year, and its business co-op includes three four-month work terms between second and fourth year, for 12 months of work experience.
Smith doesn't offer co-op. Instead, students do internships with support from Smith's Career Advancement Centre, which Smith says is Canada's #1 career services team. Hundreds of recruiters come to Smith each year. If structured co-op terms are a must for you, Laurier's model is built around them. If you'd rather find your own internships with career centre support, Smith's model fits that.
How should you choose between business programs?
Start with the format you want: when business courses start, co-op or internships, the city and the cost. Then visit if you can.
Rankings get a lot of attention, but these questions usually matter more day to day:
- Do I want to start business in first year? Smith, Rotman, Schulich and Laurier start in year one. Ivey starts in year three.
- Do I want co-op or summer internships?
- What city do I want to live in for four years?
- How big is the program and how much will I see the same classmates?
- What does exchange look like?
- What happens outside class? At Smith, clubs and competitions are a big part of it. Our guide to case competitions at Smith Commerce explains how they work.
- What's the cost, including housing? Our tuition and scholarships guide breaks down Smith's numbers.
- How do I feel on campus? Visit if you can.
FAQ
Is Queen's Commerce better than Ivey? They're different models. Smith is direct entry with business from year one. Ivey offers AEO status to high school students, who spend two years in another Western program before starting the HBA in year three. The right fit depends on what you want.
Can I apply to both Queen's Commerce and Ivey AEO? Yes. They're separate applications. Ivey AEO requires applying to Western through OUAC and completing Ivey's own supplemental application.
Does Queen's Commerce have co-op? No. Smith students do internships with support from the Career Advancement Centre.
Which programs need a supplementary application? Smith, Ivey AEO and Schulich all require one. Check each school's website for current details.
Which school is the hardest to get into? Schools don't publish comparable acceptance rates, so we can't fairly rank them. For Smith's requirements, see our requirements and acceptance rate guide.
Where can I learn more about first year at Smith? Read our guide to first year in Queen's Commerce, check the FAQ, or send us a question.
